Skip to content
← All articlesEngineering

Software Code Audit: What to Check Before You Commit

A practical software code audit guide for CTOs and founders: what to review, how to score findings and when to bring in an outside team before a big decision.

At some point most product owners face the same question: can we trust this codebase? Maybe you inherited it from a previous vendor. Maybe you are about to invest in a product that someone else built, or you are planning to hand the work to a new team. A software code audit gives you a structured, evidence-based answer instead of a gut feeling.

This guide explains what a code audit covers, how to run one, and how to turn the findings into decisions.

When a code audit is worth doing

An audit is not a routine task. It earns its cost at moments of change or doubt:

  • Taking over a product from another vendor or an in-house team that has left.
  • Before an acquisition or investment, as part of technical due diligence.
  • Before a major rebuild or migration, so you know what to keep.
  • After repeated incidents or slow delivery, when the cause is unclear.
  • Before moving to an offshore or dedicated team, so the new team starts with an honest picture.

If the code is healthy and the team is shipping steadily, a full audit is probably unnecessary. Regular code review covers most day-to-day quality needs.

What a good audit covers

A useful audit looks beyond style and formatting. Work through these areas:

  1. Architecture and structure. Are responsibilities separated clearly? Can you explain how a request travels through the system? Is there a sensible boundary between modules?
  2. Code quality and readability. Naming, function size, duplication, dead code and consistency of patterns.
  3. Security. Authentication and authorisation logic, input validation, secrets in the repository, and known risks from the OWASP Top 10.
  4. Dependencies. Outdated or unmaintained libraries, licence issues and known vulnerabilities. See our note on dependency management and supply chain security.
  5. Testing. What is covered, what is not, and whether the tests actually fail when something breaks.
  6. Build, deployment and environments. Can a new developer build the project from the README? Is deployment automated and repeatable?
  7. Data and database design. Schema quality, indexing, migration history and backup practice.
  8. Documentation and knowledge risk. Is the system understandable without the original authors?

A simple scoring approach

Raw lists of issues overwhelm people. Score each finding on two axes: impact if it goes wrong and effort to fix. A basic table is enough:

Finding type Typical action
High impact, low effort Fix immediately
High impact, high effort Plan as a funded project
Low impact, low effort Batch into routine maintenance
Low impact, high effort Record and accept for now

Group findings by area and give each area a plain status: healthy, needs attention or critical. Executives rarely need more than that on the first page of the report.

How to run the audit

1. Define the question

“Is the code good?” is too vague. Ask something specific: “Can we safely add payments in six months?” or “What would it cost to hand this to a new team?” The question decides how deep each area goes.

2. Get access and context

You need read access to the repository, history, issue tracker and deployment configuration. Talk to the people who wrote or maintain it. Their explanations of why things look the way they do are often more valuable than the code alone.

3. Combine automated tools and manual review

Static analysis, dependency scanners and secret scanners find a lot quickly. They cannot judge whether the design fits the business. Pair them with manual review of the riskiest parts: authentication, payments, data access and anything that has caused incidents.

4. Look at the history

Commit history shows where the churn is. Files that change constantly and attract bug fixes are usually where the real problems live. A single contributor behind most of the code signals knowledge risk.

5. Report with evidence

Every finding should point to a file, a pattern or a reproducible behaviour. Avoid opinions presented as facts. Separate what you verified from what you suspect.

Common mistakes

  • Auditing everything equally. Focus on the code that carries business risk.
  • Treating the audit as blame. The goal is a plan, not a verdict on the previous team.
  • Producing a report and stopping. An audit without a prioritised roadmap changes nothing.
  • Ignoring operations. Great code with no monitoring or backups is still a risk.
  • Using only tools. Scanners miss design and business-logic flaws.

Turning findings into a plan

A good audit ends with three things: a short summary a non-technical stakeholder can read in five minutes, a prioritised backlog with rough effort bands, and a recommendation. The recommendation is usually one of: continue as is, stabilise and improve, refactor in stages, or rebuild specific parts. Our guide to managing technical debt shows how to schedule that work without freezing the roadmap.

Getting an independent view

An outside reviewer has no stake in defending past decisions and can compare what they see against many other codebases. That independence is the main reason founders and investors commission audits instead of relying on the team that built the product.

AkMo Technologies helps international teams assess existing applications and then maintain or improve them through our application support and maintenance service, or through a dedicated development team. If you are weighing up an inherited or acquired codebase, contact us and we will discuss the scope of a review.

Let’s build what’s next.

Tell us about your platform, your product idea or the systems you want to modernise. Someone from our Chennai engineering team will get back to you personally.