Skip to content
← All articlesAI & Data

Testing AI Features: How to Evaluate LLM Output Quality

How to test AI features in your app: build an evaluation set, choose metrics, automate regression checks and add human review so LLM quality stays reliable.

Traditional software testing rests on a simple promise: the same input gives the same output. AI features break that promise. A large language model (LLM) can answer the same question in different words each time, and a small prompt edit or a provider model update can quietly change behaviour across your whole product.

That does not mean AI features cannot be tested. It means the testing approach has to change. This guide explains how product and engineering teams can build a practical quality process around LLM-powered features.

Why standard tests are not enough

A unit test that checks for an exact string will fail constantly on LLM output, even when the answer is perfectly good. The opposite problem is worse: tests that pass while the feature gives confident but wrong answers.

Common failure modes to plan for:

  • Factual errors: plausible answers that are simply untrue.
  • Ignoring instructions: wrong format, wrong tone, or answers outside the allowed scope.
  • Regressions after changes: a prompt tweak fixes one case and breaks five others.
  • Unsafe or off-brand output: content your company would never want to publish.
  • Prompt injection: user or document text that tries to override your instructions.

Step 1: Build an evaluation set

The foundation of AI quality work is a curated set of test cases, often called an evaluation set or “golden set”. Each case contains an input, the context the model would receive, and a description of what a good answer looks like.

Good sources for cases:

  • real (anonymised) user questions from support tickets or logs
  • edge cases your support team already knows are difficult
  • adversarial inputs, such as attempts to bypass instructions
  • cases where the correct behaviour is to refuse or say “I don’t know”

Start with 50 to 100 well-chosen cases rather than thousands of weak ones. Review the set regularly and add every real-world failure you discover, so the same bug cannot return unnoticed.

Step 2: Decide what “good” means

Define quality in terms your business cares about, then break it into checkable criteria. For a support assistant, that might be:

Criterion How to check
Correctness Compare against a reference answer or source document
Groundedness Does the answer only use the provided context?
Format Valid JSON, length limits, required fields present
Tone and policy Follows brand voice; avoids prohibited topics
Safety Refuses harmful requests; no leaked system prompt

Write these criteria down. Vague goals such as “answers should be good” cannot be automated or agreed on between teams.

Step 3: Combine three kinds of checks

No single method is enough. Mature teams layer them.

Deterministic checks. Use ordinary code for anything that can be verified exactly: schema validation, required keywords, forbidden phrases, response length, correct tool or function being called. These are fast, cheap and reliable.

Model-assisted grading. A second LLM can score answers against your rubric, for example “does this answer contradict the source text?” This scales well, but treat it as a tool, not an oracle. Calibrate it by comparing its scores with human judgement on a sample, and keep the grader prompt versioned.

Human review. People remain the final authority on nuance, tone and domain accuracy. Review a regular sample of outputs, plus every case where automated scores disagree or drop.

Step 4: Automate regression checks

Run your evaluation set automatically whenever something changes:

  • a prompt or system instruction is edited
  • the model or model version is switched
  • retrieval settings, documents or tools change
  • a dependency in the AI pipeline is upgraded

Wire this into your CI pipeline in the same way as other tests (see our guide to CI/CD with GitHub Actions). Track pass rates per criterion over time and set a threshold that blocks a release when quality drops. Because outputs vary, run borderline cases more than once and look at trends rather than single results.

Step 5: Monitor after launch

Pre-release testing never covers everything real users will type. In production:

  • log prompts, responses, retrieved context and model version (respecting privacy rules)
  • give users a simple thumbs up/down or “report a problem” option
  • sample live traffic into your review queue
  • feed confirmed failures back into the evaluation set

If your feature uses retrieval, test that layer separately, since many wrong answers come from retrieving the wrong documents rather than from the model itself. Our RAG explainer for product teams covers how that pipeline fits together.

A simple starting checklist

  • Written definition of good and unacceptable output
  • Evaluation set of at least 50 real and adversarial cases
  • Deterministic checks for format and policy rules
  • A calibrated model-based grader, if used
  • Human review process with named owners
  • Automated run on every prompt, model or retrieval change
  • Production logging, feedback and an incident path

Who should own AI quality?

AI testing sits between engineering, QA and the product owner. Engineers build the pipeline, QA specialists design cases and exploratory attacks, and the product owner defines what acceptable means. Teams that leave it to developers alone tend to test only the happy path.

If you lack in-house capacity, an offshore QA or dedicated team can maintain the evaluation set, run review cycles and report quality trends every sprint, provided communication and ownership are clear.

Next steps

AkMo Technologies helps teams build quality processes around new AI features through our software testing services, and can embed engineers and testers in your product team through dedicated teams. If you are planning an AI feature or worried about the quality of one already live, contact us to discuss your situation. For cost planning alongside quality, read our guide to LLM cost control.

Let’s build what’s next.

Tell us about your platform, your product idea or the systems you want to modernise. Someone from our Chennai engineering team will get back to you personally.